{
 "_about": "Pilot question set (20). Ground truth written from the paper texts in dataset/pilot/txt, NOT from the OKF bundle or the RAG index. key_facts are what a correct answer must contain; the judge grades correct / partial / wrong / abstained against them. Paper ids: W7163143446 = Vráble (Furholt et al.), W7166088190 = Poland archaeobotany (Juzwinska et al.), W7202185506 = Alsace funerary (Waldvogel), W7204009876 = Buh-Dniester post-LBK (Kiosak & Kotova), W7225183261 = Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye (Kroon et al.).",
 "types": {
  "single": "answer is in one paper (specific fact)",
  "cross": "needs facts from two or more papers",
  "synthesis": "open question, needs several facts and a summary; vague wording on purpose where noted",
  "unanswerable": "plausible but NOT stated in the dataset; correct behaviour is to say so"
 },
 "questions": [
  {
   "id": "Q01",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446"
   ],
   "question": "How many houses were located by the archaeomagnetic prospection at the Neolithic settlement of Vráble, and into how many neighbourhoods are they grouped?",
   "ground_truth": "At least 313 houses, grouped into three spatially distinct neighbourhoods of originally around 15 ha each.",
   "key_facts": [
    "at least 313 houses",
    "three neighbourhoods",
    "about 15 ha each"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q02",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446"
   ],
   "question": "In the Vráble mass deposition, how many headless skeletons had been counted by the end of the 2024 excavations, over what length of the ditch, and what had the 2022 count been?",
   "ground_truth": "At least 77 headless skeletons plus one complete skeleton, all within the first 25 m of the ditch, with the end of the deposition not yet found. In 2022 a minimum of 37 skeletons, 36 of them headless, had been reported.",
   "key_facts": [
    "at least 77 headless skeletons (and one complete skeleton)",
    "within the first 25 m of the ditch",
    "2022: minimum 37 skeletons, 36 headless"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q03",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446"
   ],
   "question": "How was the Vráble mass deposition dated, and what date range resulted?",
   "ground_truth": "By 14C analysis of rib samples from 12 headless skeletons and of seven single femora; all gave very similar dates of 5300/5210 to 5050/4950 cal BCE.",
   "key_facts": [
    "rib samples from 12 headless skeletons",
    "seven single femora",
    "5300/5210-5050/4950 cal BCE"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q04",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7166088190"
   ],
   "question": "How many soil samples were analysed from the two LBK sites in southeastern Poland (Łańcut and Zwięczyca), and how were the plant remains extracted?",
   "ground_truth": "155 soil samples from the LBK phases: 97 from Łańcut (1,142 L) and 57 from Zwięczyca (679 L), plus one sample of mixed LBK and Malice pottery. The plant material was extracted by flotation using 0.5 and 1 mm mesh sieves.",
   "key_facts": [
    "155 samples",
    "97 from Łańcut, 57 from Zwięczyca",
    "flotation",
    "0.5 mm and 1 mm mesh"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q05",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7166088190"
   ],
   "question": "Were hazelnut remains found at the Polish LBK sites, and if so, how many and where?",
   "ground_truth": "More than 100 fragments of hazelnut (Corylus avellana) shell were found at Łańcut; hazelnut was absent at Zwięczyca. The authors suggest the nuts were gathered, because of their high fat and protein content.",
   "key_facts": [
    "more than 100 fragments",
    "at Łańcut",
    "absent at Zwięczyca"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q06",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7204009876"
   ],
   "question": "What gap between the end of the LBK and the arrival of the Early Trypillians did the Bayesian interval query estimate for the Southern Buh and Dniester region?",
   "ground_truth": "The interval function gave a gap of 371 to 602 years (95.4% probability), or 418 to 524 years at 68.3%.",
   "key_facts": [
    "371-602 years at 95.4%",
    "418-524 years at 68.3%"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q07",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7202185506"
   ],
   "question": "How many LBK inhumations did the Alsace Plain dataset contain, from how many sites, and how many Grossgartach inhumations?",
   "ground_truth": "LBK: 297 inhumations (minimum number of individuals 305) from 30 sites. Grossgartach: 228 inhumations (MNI 236) from nine sites.",
   "key_facts": [
    "297 LBK inhumations (MNI 305)",
    "30 sites",
    "228 Grossgartach inhumations",
    "nine sites"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q08",
   "type": "single",
   "papers": [
    "W7202185506"
   ],
   "question": "How does body orientation in LBK graves differ between Lower and Upper Alsace?",
   "ground_truth": "In Lower Alsace 31% of individuals with known orientation have the head to the west ('antipodic'), contrary to the usual LBK head-east practice. In Upper Alsace 92% have the head to the east, as in the Danube Basin.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Lower Alsace 31% head west",
    "Upper Alsace 92% head east"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q09",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7225183261",
    "W7163143446"
   ],
   "question": "How do the papers interpret the function of LBK enclosures in the Rhineland, in Hesbaye and at Vráble?",
   "ground_truth": "Rhineland (Kroon et al.): enclosures appear from house generation XII onward; their size, slope location, multiple entrances and unclosed ring ditches make fortifications unlikely, a socio-ritual gathering place is considered, and their late appearance may signal stress or violence. Hesbaye: likely defensive, with the defensive value coming from the palisade rather than the ditches. Vráble (Furholt et al.): a 1.3 km double ditch with at least six entrances surrounds only one of the three neighbourhoods and the entrances face away from the others, so the enclosure is seen as directed against other members of the same community rather than an outside threat; human bodies were deposited in the ditches.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Rhineland: unlikely fortifications, possibly socio-ritual",
    "Hesbaye: likely defensive, palisade",
    "Vráble: encloses one of three neighbourhoods, entrances face away, directed against own community"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q10",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7204009876",
    "W7163143446",
    "W7225183261",
    "W7202185506"
   ],
   "question": "What end dates do the papers give for the LBK in the Southern Buh/Dniester region, at Vráble, in the Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye corridor (Bayesian Model 6) and in the Alsace Plain?",
   "ground_truth": "Southern Buh/Dniester (Kiosak & Kotova): end of LBK 5207-5048 cal BC (68.3%) or 5211-5010 cal BC (95.4%) in the overlapping-phases model. Vráble: occupation ends around 5000-4950 cal BCE. Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye (Kroon et al., Model 6): latest possible end 5042-4986 BC (68.3%) or 5069-4939 BC (95.4%). Alsace Plain (Waldvogel): LBK occupation between 5300 and 4950 BC.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Buh/Dniester 5207-5048 (68.3%) / 5211-5010 (95.4%)",
    "Vráble end around 5000-4950 cal BCE",
    "Kroon Model 6 5042-4986 (68.3%) / 5069-4939 (95.4%)",
    "Alsace until 4950 BC"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q11",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446",
    "W7204009876",
    "W7225183261"
   ],
   "question": "Which papers discuss the radiocarbon calibration curve plateau around the end of the LBK, and what do they conclude about it?",
   "ground_truth": "Furholt et al. (Vráble): a flat section of the calibration curve between 5210 and 5000 cal BCE prevents a more precise chronology of the mass deposition and also hinders testing LBK chronologies with absolute dates. Kiosak & Kotova: the end of the LBK falls on the 'infamous' late 6th-millennium BC plateau, which stretches the calibration of some dates (such as TKA-20833). Kroon et al.: considered a calibration-curve plateau as one possible cause of the poor model fit, but a simulation with simulated dates (Model 5) showed that neither the model structure nor the shape of IntCal20 explains it; the problem lies in a mismatch between dates and the overarching typochronology.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Vráble: plateau 5210-5000 cal BCE hinders precision",
    "Buh/Dniester: late 6th millennium plateau stretches calibration of dates",
    "Kroon: plateau tested via simulation and ruled out as the explanation"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q12",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7166088190",
    "W7202185506",
    "W7225183261"
   ],
   "question": "When does the LBK first appear in southeastern Poland, in the Alsace Plain, in Dutch Limburg and in the Rhineland according to the papers?",
   "ground_truth": "Southeastern Poland: around 5300 bc, during the Pre-Music Note phase. Alsace Plain: 5300 BC (LBK phases II to V, until 4950 BC). Dutch Limburg: around 5250 BC (Modderman Ib). Rhineland: late 54th century BC (house generation I).",
   "key_facts": [
    "SE Poland ~5300 (Pre-Music Note)",
    "Alsace 5300 BC",
    "Limburg ~5250 BC (Modderman Ib)",
    "Rhineland late 54th century BC"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q13",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7204009876",
    "W7225183261"
   ],
   "question": "Which papers discuss hunter-gatherer or Mesolithic-descended groups living alongside or after the LBK farmers, and what is the evidence?",
   "ground_truth": "Kiosak & Kotova (Southern Buh/Dniester): ceramic hunter-gatherers ('para-Neolithic'); 69 radiocarbon dates give a bimodal distribution with a pre-LBK peak, a decline during LBK expansion and a renewed peak after the LBK collapse, which the authors read as a hunter-gatherer revival before the Early Trypillian expansion. Kroon et al. (Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye): Swifterbant communities with strong ties to Late Mesolithic groups lived in the wetlands of the Netherlands and adjacent Belgium; they interacted with early farmers and integrated domestic animals (as of 4450 BC) and crops (as of 4200 BC); Mesolithic populations are continuous in Limburg.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Buh/Dniester: para-Neolithic ceramic hunter-gatherers, second radiocarbon peak after LBK",
    "Kroon: Swifterbant with Late Mesolithic ties",
    "domestic animals from 4450 BC, crops from 4200 BC"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q14",
   "type": "cross",
   "papers": [
    "W7202185506",
    "W7225183261"
   ],
   "question": "Which post-LBK cultures are discussed for the Alsace Plain and for the Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye corridor, and which appear in both?",
   "ground_truth": "Alsace Plain (Waldvogel): the Hinkelstein, Grossgartach and Rössen sequence. Rhineland-Limburg-Hesbaye (Kroon et al.): Grossgartach (GG), Rössen (RÖ), Blicquy/Villeneuve-Saint-Germain (BVSG) and Swifterbant (SWB). Grossgartach and Rössen appear in both.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Alsace: Hinkelstein, Grossgartach, Rössen",
    "Kroon: GG, RÖ, BVSG, SWB",
    "shared: Grossgartach and Rössen"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q15",
   "type": "synthesis",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446"
   ],
   "style": "vague",
   "question": "What is the story with the headless skeletons found at the end of the LBK?",
   "ground_truth": "At Vráble (Slovakia), a mass deposition of at least 77 headless skeletons was found in the outer ditch of an enclosed LBK settlement, dated to about 5300/5210-5050/4950 cal BCE; the heads are missing (cutmarks suggest cutting with sharp tools) and little else is known, so the motive is open. Interpretations discussed: headhunting, massacre (made less likely by patterned placements elsewhere), human sacrifice or a special burial rite; the authors put it in a context of similar late-LBK ditch depositions (Herxheim, Asparn-Schletz, Talheim and others) and argue against explaining it as modern-style war over land, preferring an immanentist cosmology. Aspects such as aDNA, isotopes and kinship are still under analysis.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Vráble, at least 77 headless skeletons in the ditch",
    "heads missing",
    "interpretations open: headhunting, massacre, sacrifice, burial rite",
    "compared with Herxheim, Asparn-Schletz, Talheim",
    "analyses still under way"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q16",
   "type": "synthesis",
   "papers": [
    "W7163143446",
    "W7204009876",
    "W7225183261"
   ],
   "question": "How well established is the absolute chronology of the end of the LBK across these papers, and what methodological problems do they report?",
   "ground_truth": "Not well established. Furholt et al.: LBK chronologies are largely based on pottery decoration and are not controlled by absolute dates because of the calibration plateau (5210-5000 cal BCE). Kiosak & Kotova: the Kyiv laboratory series from 1998-2008 is suspicious and fails cross-laboratory validation, dates on total organic carbon in pottery (TOCC) are unreliable, and the end of LBK falls on the plateau; they use Bayesian modelling in OxCal. Kroon et al.: the dataset is sparse (482 dates reviewed, a smaller high-quality subset) and mostly charred cereals with a risk of residual or intrusive dates; the overarching typochronology model has poor agreement (Amodel 7.4%) while regional models fit well; they present two alternative models and call for renewed absolute dating.",
   "key_facts": [
    "calibration plateau",
    "Kyiv lab series 1998-2008 and TOCC dates unreliable",
    "sparse dataset, charred cereals risk residual or intrusive",
    "typochronology vs radiocarbon mismatch, two models",
    "call for more absolute dating"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q17",
   "type": "synthesis",
   "papers": [
    "W7202185506",
    "W7204009876"
   ],
   "question": "What do the papers say about whether archaeological cultures defined by pottery style correspond to real social groups?",
   "ground_truth": "Waldvogel (Alsace): funerary variability (body orientation and position, grave layout, grave goods) frequently transcends chrono-cultural divisions based on ceramic styles and cannot be correlated with sex or age, so it questions the view of archaeological cultures as coherent social entities and suggests social units rooted in territories. Kiosak & Kotova: the 'Buh-Dniester culture' is effectively an umbrella term for diverse sites, Savran-style pottery is not exclusive to one period, and ceramic styles of hunter-gatherer pottery do not appear to have purely chronological significance; isolated traits attributed to cultures can mislead.",
   "key_facts": [
    "Alsace: funerary variability transcends ceramic-defined cultures",
    "Alsace: not correlated with sex or age",
    "Buh-Dniester is an umbrella term",
    "Savran pottery not exclusive to the interval, styles not purely chronological"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q18",
   "type": "unanswerable",
   "papers": [],
   "question": "What was the average stature of the adults buried at Vráble, and what ratio of males to females did the osteological analysis find?",
   "ground_truth": "Not reported. The Vráble paper presents only preliminary osteological observations (for example that subadults seem underrepresented) and states the full osteological analysis is still to be carried out.",
   "key_facts": [
    "not stated in the dataset"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q19",
   "type": "unanswerable",
   "papers": [],
   "question": "Which mitochondrial haplogroups did the ancient DNA analysis of the Vráble headless skeletons reveal?",
   "ground_truth": "Not reported. aDNA analyses of the Vráble material are listed as under way; aDNA results are mentioned only for Asparn-Schletz (92 individuals).",
   "key_facts": [
    "not stated in the dataset"
   ]
  },
  {
   "id": "Q20",
   "type": "unanswerable",
   "papers": [],
   "question": "What radiocarbon dates were obtained for features at Zwięczyca site 3?",
   "ground_truth": "None reported. The radiocarbon dating in the Polish paper covers eight samples from Łańcut only; Zwięczyca is dated by typological features (Pre-Music Note to Želiezovce phases), not by radiocarbon dates in this paper.",
   "key_facts": [
    "not stated for Zwięczyca",
    "the eight dates are from Łańcut"
   ]
  }
 ]
}
